← Web Annex

Many Instruments, One Sky

Joint inversion of overdetermined space-physics data: how ground magnetometers, a satellite and a radar are combined into one estimate of the ionospheric current, and how to say honestly what that estimate can and cannot resolve

More data than unknowns, and still not enough

The companion page, Reading the Sky from the Ground, asked what one ground array sees. This page asks the next question. Several instruments look at the same ionosphere: magnetometers on the ground, a magnetometer on a satellite a few hundred kilometres above the current, a radar that measures plasma velocity along its beams. Each samples the sky differently, each has its own noise, and none of them sees everything. How are they combined into one estimate of the current, and how does one say, with numbers, what that estimate can and cannot resolve?

The answer is linear inverse theory, and its central fact is easy to state and easy to forget. A problem can be overdetermined, with many more measurements than unknowns, and still be ill-posed: some combinations of the unknowns change the data so little that the noise hides them, and some change the data not at all. Adding more of the same measurement does not fix that. Adding a measurement that looks from a different direction can.

satellite, ~450 km: B above the sheet current sheet, ~110 km FACs ground magnetometers: B below the sheet radar: line-of-sight velocity
Three ways of looking. Ground magnetometers measure the field below the current, the satellite measures it above (and crosses the field-aligned currents, FACs), and the radar measures one velocity component in the current-carrying layer. Heights are to scale only roughly.
The same instruments in map view. Station dots are real IMAGE magnetometer sites (public coordinates[7]); the satellite track and the radar fan are schematic. Points, a line and a wedge: three very different samplings of one two-dimensional current.

1.1The question each instrument answers

What each instrument measures, and the part of the current it is blind to. DF = divergence-free, CF = curl-free (tab 3).
InstrumentMeasuresSamplesBlind to
Ground magnetometersΔB (X north, Y east, Z down) ~110 km below the currenta few dozen fixed points, continuouslythe CF current with its FACs (exactly, for radial field lines); fine structure smaller than ~the height
Low-orbit satelliteΔB a few hundred km above the currentone line, a few minutes per passeverything off its track; time evolution
Radarone component of the plasma velocity v, hence of E = −v×Ba fan of beams, every minute or sothe other velocity component; the current itself unless the conductance is known

Interactive · overdetermined but ill-posed

Two unknowns, m1 and m2; twelve noisy measurements, each a straight line in the (m1, m2) plane. If all instruments look from nearly the same direction, the lines are nearly parallel: twelve equations, but the combination along the lines is barely constrained. Widen the spread of viewing directions and watch the uncertainty ellipse and the smaller singular value.

The ellipse is the 1σ posterior region for σ = 1 noise. Its semi-axes are 1/si, the reciprocal singular values of G, along the right singular vectors. Doubling the number of near-parallel measurements shrinks it only by √2; widening the spread shrinks the long axis by orders of magnitude.

The rest of the page builds this up. Tab 2 writes down the forward models d = Gm for each instrument. Tab 3 introduces the standard basis for ionospheric currents, spherical elementary current systems, and shows exactly what the ground cannot see. Tabs 4 and 5 are the linear algebra: least squares, priors, the singular value decomposition, and the resolution matrix, which is the honest answer to “what does this estimate mean?”. Tab 6 combines instruments. Tab 7 is about checking an inversion before believing it. Tab 8 runs the inversion live on two hours of real IMAGE data from a published event.

Simplifications used throughout. The ionospheric current is a thin sheet at 110 km. Field lines are taken radial (vertical); at Fennoscandian latitudes they are tilted about 12° from vertical, and the consequences are stated where they matter. Induced currents in the ground are ignored, although on the companion page they are shown to matter for the vertical component. Every synthetic number is generated live by the stated models with a seeded random generator.

Related on this annex: Reading the Sky from the Ground (what one ground array sees, and how to test for motion) · The Magnetosphere (animated introduction: solar wind, Birkeland currents, substorms) · Four-Way Satellite Convergence (combining what different instruments see).

All numbers on this page are either taken from the cited literature or generated live in your browser by the stated synthetic models, except the IMAGE data of the “A real interval” tab, which are credited there. Synthetic noise uses a seeded generator, so “New noise” gives a fresh but reproducible realisation. The linear algebra (Jacobi SVD, Cholesky) is written in the page; no library is loaded.

← Web Annex